Skip to content

20 November 2026Inventory, food cost & wasteBy The ServeAround team17 min read

Wine list costing: margin by the glass and bottle

A bottle and a glass of the same wine need different margins, and the open bottle policy decides whether either works. How to cost both, price the ladder and review the list.

Illustration for wine list costing: a wine glass, a tumbler and a cocktail beside a slice of lemon, in yellow and coral on cream.

A house white costs 40 a bottle and sells for 160 before tax. That is a 25 per cent cost, a comfortable figure, and nobody worries about it. The same wine sells by the glass at 40 a glass, and on paper the glass looks even better: a 750 millilitre bottle holds more than four 175 millilitre glasses, so the bottle should bring in more than 170. In practice it often brings in less than the bottle sale, and nobody notices until the count.

That gap is what wine list costing is for. A bottle sold whole has a fixed cost and a fixed price. A bottle sold by the glass has a cost that depends on how many glasses it really yields, and that depends on how long open bottles last, how generously staff pour and how many glasses go to tastings or down the sink. The open bottle policy, more than the price, decides whether by the glass makes money.

This guide shows how to cost a bottle and a glass, how to price glasses from the yield you actually get, how to build a price ladder that earns more cash on better wines, and how to review the list each month. Every wine, price and percentage in it is an example, not a benchmark.

What wine list costing covers

Costing a wine list means knowing, for every wine you sell, what it costs you, what it sells for and what it leaves after the liquid is paid for. It covers bottles, glasses, carafes and half bottles, and it covers the losses each format carries. It sits alongside the drinks figure for the whole bar, which our guide to beverage cost percentage by category shows how to split so a wine list cannot hide inside a healthy average.

The aim is not the lowest possible cost on every line. It is a list where every wine earns its place: some by the cash they leave, some by the guests they bring, and none by accident.

The bottle: the simple half

A bottle sold whole is the easy part, because what you buy is what you sell. The cost is the price on the invoice, after any discount or delivery charge you allocate to it.

Bottle cost percentage = bottle cost ÷ bottle price before tax × 100

Cash margin per bottle = bottle price before tax − bottle cost

The house white costs 40 and sells for 168 including 5 per cent tax, so its price before tax is 160. Its cost is 25 per cent of the price, and each bottle leaves 120.

Always take tax out of the price first, and any service charge added on top. A percentage worked out on the price including tax looks better than it is, and the habit spreads to every line on the list.

The glass: yield is everything

A glass is a share of a bottle, so its cost is the bottle's cost divided by the number of glasses the bottle really gives. The theoretical number is easy: 750 millilitres makes six 125 millilitre glasses, just over four 175 millilitre glasses, or three 250 millilitre glasses.

The real number is lower. A bottle opened late in the evening and not finished may be poured away the next day. A glass is poured for a guest to taste before they order. A bartender pours a generous 190 millilitres into a 175 millilitre glass. A bottle turns out to be corked. Each of these reduces the glasses you are paid for, and the cost of the ones you sell goes up.

So cost each glass from the yield you get, not the yield the bottle could give. Measure it for a few weeks: bottles opened for by the glass service, against glasses sold. Most venues find a figure noticeably below the theoretical one.

Costing a glass from the real yield

Take the house white again: 40 a bottle, sold by the 175 millilitre glass at 42 including tax, or 40 before tax.

  • At the theoretical yield of 4.29 glasses, each glass costs 9.33, and the cost is 23.3 per cent of the price. A bottle brings in about 171 before tax.
  • At a real yield of 4 glasses, each glass costs 10, which is 25 per cent. A bottle brings in 160.
  • At a real yield of 3.5 glasses, because some open bottles are poured away and some glasses go to tastings, each glass costs 11.43, which is 28.6 per cent. A bottle brings in 140.

The last line is common, and it changes the picture. Sold whole, the bottle left 120. Sold by the glass at this yield, it leaves 100. By the glass looked like the better earner on paper and earns less in practice, and only a measured yield shows it.

Pricing a glass from the yield you get

The fix is to price the glass from the real yield, so that a bottle sold by the glass earns at least what it would earn sold whole, with something extra for the risk.

Glass price before tax = target revenue per bottle ÷ real glasses per bottle

To earn the same 160 before tax from the house white at 3.5 glasses a bottle, each glass needs to sell for 45.71 before tax, about 48 including tax. Many venues go a little higher still, because the glass format carries more risk and more handling than a bottle. Our guide to menu pricing sets this method beside five others.

Then work on the yield, because every glass you stop losing is margin you keep without touching the price.

Why glasses and bottles need different margins

A bottle and a glass of the same wine are different products. The bottle is sold once, with no waste and little handling. The glass is poured several times, from a bottle that starts losing value the moment it is opened. It is reasonable, and usual, for the glass to carry a higher markup than the bottle.

There is also a guest reason. Guests who order by the glass are often trying a wine, drinking less or choosing something for one course. They compare glass prices with each other more than with the bottle. Guests who order a bottle compare it with the rest of the bottle list and with what they would pay in a shop. Each format needs pricing for the comparison guests actually make.

The open bottle policy decides the margin

How long an open bottle stays on sale, and what happens to it then, decides more of the glass margin than the price does. Write the policy down and make it the same for every shift.

  • How long each style stays on sale once opened: fewer days for light whites and sparkling, more for fortified wines.
  • How bottles are closed and stored overnight: stoppers, the fridge, inert gas or a preservation system.
  • Who decides when a bottle goes, and where that is recorded.
  • Which wines are open for tasting, and how many tastings a guest is offered.
  • What happens to a bottle near the end of its time: a staff tasting, a kitchen sauce or the sink, each recorded.

A clear policy turns a vague loss into a known one. You may decide to accept losing part of a bottle on a rare wine you want on the glass list, but that is then a choice, costed and priced in.

Preservation systems, costed

Inert gas and needle based systems keep open wine fresh for much longer and let a venue pour better wines by the glass. They cost money to buy and run, so cost them like any other investment.

Work out what the system saves: the glasses you would otherwise pour away, times the cost of each. If it saves one glass from each of ten premium bottles a week, at 15 a glass, it saves 150 a week. Set that against the running cost and the price of the system, and you know whether it pays for itself and how quickly. It usually pays on expensive wines and rarely on the house wine, which sells fast enough to need no help.

Cash margin, not just percentage, on bottles

On bottles, a flat markup is the most common mistake. Multiplying every bottle's cost by the same number makes cheap wines good value and expensive wines very expensive, so guests trade down and the expensive bottles sit in the cellar.

A sliding markup does the opposite. The multiple falls as the cost rises, so the percentage cost goes up on better bottles, but the cash each bottle leaves goes up too. Guests see fairer prices at the top of the list, and the venue earns more from each premium bottle it sells. This is the same idea as gross profit per dish: a higher percentage can be a better sale when the cash is larger.

A worked price ladder

Here is an illustrative ladder of five bottles, with costs and prices before tax.

  • A bottle costing 30, priced at 3.5 times cost, sells for 105. Its cost is 28.6 per cent, and it leaves 75.
  • A bottle costing 45, at 3.2 times, sells for 144. Its cost is 31.3 per cent, and it leaves 99.
  • A bottle costing 70, at 2.8 times, sells for 196. Its cost is 35.7 per cent, and it leaves 126.
  • A bottle costing 120, at 2.4 times, sells for 288. Its cost is 41.7 per cent, and it leaves 168.
  • A bottle costing 250, at 1.9 times, sells for 475. Its cost is 52.6 per cent, and it leaves 225.

Read down the list and the percentage gets worse while the cash gets steadily better. A table that moves from the second bottle to the fourth leaves 69 more, even though the percentage looks less healthy. That is the sale you want staff to make.

The house wine: the volume engine

The house wine usually sells more than any other line on the list, by the glass, the carafe and the bottle. Small changes to it move the whole category. A supplier price rise on the house white matters more than a new premium bottle, and a better yield on it matters more than any preservation system.

Review the house wines first every month. Check the invoice price, the glass yield and the share of wine sales they take, and re-cost them whenever the supplier changes the price or the vintage.

How many wines to pour by the glass

Every wine on the glass list means an open bottle, and every open bottle is a risk. A long glass list looks generous and loses money unless each wine sells fast enough to finish its bottles on time.

Size the glass list to your sales. A wine that sells fewer glasses a night than its bottle holds, after the bottle's safe open life, will lose part of every bottle. Either move it to a bottle only list, put it on a preservation system or price the loss in. Most venues are better served by a short glass list that turns over quickly than a long one that pours wine away.

The 125 millilitre glass and the law

Glass sizes are not only a pricing decision. In the UK, for example, still wine sold by the glass is sold in set measures, and venues with an alcohol licence must make the smallest measure available and let guests know about it. The measures are set by the Weights and Measures (Intoxicating Liquor) Order 1988, and elsewhere the rules differ, so check where you trade.

Whatever the rules, cost every size you offer. A 125 millilitre glass is not simply a 175 millilitre glass made smaller: guests who choose it often pay a higher price per millilitre, which is fair, and it changes the yield sum for the bottle.

Carafes and half bottles

Carafes sit between the glass and the bottle. They usually come from the same open bottles as glasses, so cost them from the same real yield. A 500 millilitre carafe from the house white at a yield of 3.5 glasses carries the same loss per millilitre as the glass.

Half bottles are sold whole, like full bottles, so they carry no open bottle loss. They cost more per millilitre to buy, so their markup is usually a little lower, but they suit guests dining alone or in pairs and can replace a glass list wine that sells too slowly.

Sparkling wine by the glass

Sparkling wine loses its fizz quickly once opened, even with a good stopper, so its yield falls faster than still wine's. A bottle with six 125 millilitre glasses that sells only four before it goes flat costs half as much again per glass as the sum on paper.

Price sparkling glasses from that real yield, keep the glass list short, and use the end of a bottle on purpose, in a cocktail or a staff tasting, rather than pouring it away. Some venues pour sparkling by the glass only at busy times, when bottles empty fast.

Fortified and dessert wines

Port, sherry, madeira and sweet wines keep much longer once opened, which makes them easier to sell by the glass. Their risk is different: they sell slowly, so stock sits on the shelf and money sits with it. Count them as stock that ties up cash, and keep only as many as you sell.

Corkage and bring your own

When guests bring their own wine, the venue loses the margin on a bottle it would otherwise have sold, and still opens, pours and washes up. Corkage pays for that. Some venues set it close to the cash margin of a mid priced bottle on their own list; others keep it low to welcome guests who bring something special. Either is a valid choice, as long as it is made on purpose and written down.

Stock value and slow sellers

A wine list is stock, and stock is cash on a shelf. A long list of slow selling bottles can hold more cash than the kitchen's whole inventory. Count the cellar's value each month and compare it with what the wine sold.

A bottle that has not sold for three months is a decision waiting to be made: put it on as a glass special, offer it to regulars or stop reordering it. The aim is a list where every bottle earns its shelf space.

When supplier prices or vintages change

Wine prices change with each shipment, each vintage and each currency move. A costing done once and never repeated is wrong within a year. Re-cost from the latest invoice whenever a wine's price changes, and check the glass yield whenever its style or size changes.

When a vintage changes, taste the new one before it goes on sale. A different vintage can change what guests will pay as much as what it costs.

Reading wine by category

Split wine sales and costs into at least two lines, by the glass and by the bottle, because they behave so differently. Add a line for sparkling if you pour it by the glass. Then read each line against its own target, so a strong bottle list cannot hide a glass list that is losing money.

The same split makes the monthly count easier to read. If the wine cost is up, the category tells you whether to look at the open bottles or the bottle list.

A monthly wine list review

  1. Re-cost every wine whose invoice price changed.
  2. Measure the glass yield for each wine poured by the glass.
  3. Compare cost and cash margin for glasses and bottles separately.
  4. List bottles with no sales in the last month, and decide on each.
  5. Check the house wines' share of wine sales and their yield.
  6. Taste anything with a new vintage and adjust the price if needed.

Keep the results in one place each month. The trend over a quarter tells you more than any single month.

Common mistakes

  • Costing glasses from the theoretical yield.
  • Applying the same markup to every bottle.
  • Running a long glass list that sells too slowly to finish bottles.
  • Leaving the open bottle policy to each shift's judgement.
  • Dividing by prices that include tax.
  • Forgetting to re-cost after a supplier price or vintage change.
  • Reading wine only as one figure with the rest of the drinks.

Where ServeAround fits

Wine list costing needs the cost of each wine, what each format sells for and how many glasses each bottle really gives. ServeAround covers the first two directly, and the counts show the third.

With inventory, part of Order Fulfillment, each wine is an item counted in litres, and each glass, carafe or bottle on the menu gets a recipe: 175 millilitres for the glass, 750 for the bottle. The recipe gives the cost, the menu price, the margin and the cost as a percentage of the price, at today's stock costs. A recipe belongs to a dish, not to one of its variations, so list the glass and the bottle as separate dishes if you want each costed and counted correctly.

Every glass and bottle rung through the point of sale takes its recipe off the expected stock. Count the cellar or the wine fridge as its own storage area, and the inventory report in Analytics sets what the counts say was used against what the recipes say the orders used, wine by wine. That gap is the open bottle loss in figures. Bottles poured away can be recorded as waste with a reason, such as spoiled, at what they cost.

Set up your menu with categories such as Wine by the glass and Wine by the bottle, and the menu report shows revenue, units and margin for each one over any dates, from the recipes' costs. It does not track open bottles or preservation systems, and margins use today's costs, not last month's. If you would like to see it with your own list, get in touch.

Questions operators ask

What markup should a wine list use?

There is no single right markup. A sliding scale, with a higher multiple on cheaper bottles and a lower one on expensive bottles, usually earns more cash and sells better wine than a flat multiple. Set it from your own costs, guests and competitors.

Should a glass cost more per millilitre than a bottle?

Usually yes. The glass carries open bottle losses and more handling, so most venues price it higher per millilitre. Price it from the real yield you measure, not from the bottle's size.

How many glasses should a bottle give?

A 750 millilitre bottle holds six 125 millilitre glasses or just over four 175 millilitre glasses. The number you should cost from is the one you actually get, measured over a few weeks, and it is usually lower.

How long can an open bottle stay on sale?

It depends on the style and how it is stored. Light whites and sparkling wines fade fastest; fortified wines last longest. Set a time for each style in your policy, taste before pouring and record what is poured away.

Is a preservation system worth it?

Work it out from the glasses it saves. On expensive wines poured by the glass it often pays for itself; on fast selling house wines it rarely does.

How do I price the house wine?

From its real yield and the cash it should leave, like any other wine, and with extra care because it sells the most. Re-cost it every time the supplier changes the price.

Should corkage cover the lost margin?

It can. Some venues set corkage near the cash margin of a mid priced bottle; others keep it low to welcome guests. Choose deliberately and write it down.

How often should the wine list be re-costed?

Re-cost a wine whenever its price or vintage changes, and review the whole list monthly. Measure glass yields at least every quarter.

The short version

Wine list costing has two halves. Bottles are simple: cost over price before tax, and the cash each one leaves. Glasses depend on the yield you really get, which the open bottle policy decides more than the price does. Cost glasses from that yield and price them so a bottle sold by the glass earns at least what it earns sold whole.

Use a sliding markup so better bottles earn more cash, keep the glass list as short as your sales allow, read glasses and bottles as separate lines and review the list every month.

Written byThe ServeAround team

Keep reading