Skip to content

17 November 2026Inventory, food cost & wasteBy The ServeAround team24 min read

Beverage cost percentage by category, not in total

Split the bar's figure into spirits, wine, beer and soft drinks and a comfortable average stops hiding the category losing money. The sums, the targets and a weekly routine.

Illustration for beverage cost percentage: a wine glass, a tumbler and a cocktail beside a slice of lemon, in yellow and coral on cream.

A bar closes the month at 23 per cent and everyone relaxes. The figure is under the 24 per cent the owner aims for, it has barely moved since last month, and nobody has been told to worry. Underneath it, spirits are running at 16 per cent, beer at 21, soft drinks at 12 and wine at 38. The wine list is losing several thousand a month, and the total is too comfortable to show it.

That is the trouble with a single beverage cost percentage. It is an average of very different kinds of drink, weighted by how much of each you sold, and an average can be healthy while one of its parts is not. Splitting the figure by category is how you see the part.

This guide shows how to choose the categories, how to get cost and sales into each one, how to read a total that moves when the mix moves, how to set a target for each category, and where to look when one of them goes wrong. Every venue, price and percentage in it is an example, not a benchmark.

Why one figure for the whole bar is not enough

The total is a weighted average. Each category's own figure is multiplied by its share of drinks sales, and the results are added up. A category that sells a lot pulls the total towards its own figure, and a category that sells little barely moves it, however badly it is doing.

So the total can stay level while every category under it changes, and it can move while nothing is wrong at all. A month with more beer and fewer cocktails will show a different total from one with the opposite mix, even if every drink was poured and priced exactly as before. Reading only the total, you cannot tell a real problem from a change in what guests ordered.

The category figures do not have that weakness. Each one compares like with like: wine with wine, beer with beer. When one of them moves, something happened in that category, and you know which shelf to walk to.

The formula for one category

The sum is the same as the one for the whole bar, applied to one category at a time. You need the cost of the drinks that category used, and the sales it made before tax.

Beverage cost percentage for a category = cost of that category's drinks used ÷ that category's sales before tax × 100

Cost of drinks used = opening stock + purchases + transfers in − transfers out − closing stock

Opening and closing stock come from the count, valued at cost. Purchases come from the invoices for the period. Transfers are stock that moved into or out of the category without being sold as a drink in it, such as wine taken by the kitchen for a sauce. The rest of this guide is mostly about getting each of those numbers into the right category, because that is where the work is.

For a single drink the same idea is called pour cost: the cost of what is in the glass over its price before tax. Our guide to pour cost works it out for a gin and tonic and a whisky sour. The category figure is what you get when you add up every drink in the category, and then check the result against the count.

Choosing the categories

The right categories are the ones that behave differently. Drinks with similar costs, similar losses and similar prices can share a line. Drinks that differ on any of those should be apart. For most bars and restaurants that gives a list like this:

  • Spirits served with a mixer.
  • Cocktails.
  • Wine by the glass.
  • Wine by the bottle.
  • Draught beer.
  • Bottled and canned beer and cider.
  • Soft drinks, juices and mixers sold on their own.
  • Hot drinks.
  • Low and no alcohol drinks.

That is nine lines, which is more than most venues need on day one. Each category needs its own sales line, its own invoices and its own part of the count, so every category you add is a little more work every week. Start with four or five: spirits and cocktails, wine, beer, and soft and hot drinks. Split one further only when you have a reason to watch it on its own.

Spirits and cocktails: one category or two

Spirits with a mixer and cocktails share most of their bottles. The same gin goes into a gin and tonic and a negroni, and the count cannot say which glass each millilitre went into. That makes a separate actual figure for cocktails hard to measure.

A practical answer is one stock category and two sales categories. Count spirits and liqueurs as one shelf. Sell cocktails and spirits with mixers as separate lines on the till. Then work out the theoretical cost of each line from its recipes, and compare their combined theoretical cost with the actual cost of the shelf. If the shelf is out, the recipes for the bigger seller are usually the first place to look.

Within cocktails, the category figure only tells you whether the list as a whole is holding. Which drinks to put in front of guests is a separate question, the one cocktail menu engineering answers, by setting each drink's popularity against the cash it leaves. The category figure is the check that sits above that work.

Wine by the glass and wine by the bottle

Wine is the category that most often hides in the total, and it usually needs two sales lines. By the glass and by the bottle use the same stock but carry different prices, different margins and very different losses.

A bottle sold whole is easy: the cost is the cost of the bottle. A bottle sold by the glass loses value the moment it is opened. Tastings, generous pours, the last glass poured away and bottles left open too long all cost money that no recipe includes. A wine list can look sound on paper and run several points worse in the count purely because of what happens to open bottles.

Keep wine as one stock category if your count cannot tell glass stock from bottle stock, and split the sales. Wine list costing, the work of pricing each wine by the glass and by the bottle, starts from the same split, and it is far easier when the sales are already apart.

Draught beer, bottles and cans

Draught and packaged beer behave differently enough to be worth separating once beer is a meaningful share of sales. A bottle or can is sold whole, so its cost is fixed and its losses are mostly breakage and drinks given away.

A keg is not sold whole. Line cleaning, the first pulls of a new keg, foam and a pint poured away because it came out flat all use beer that is never paid for. Those are normal losses in a well run cellar, but they put draught on a different footing from bottles. If the two share a category, a good month for bottles can hide a cellar that is wasting beer.

Soft drinks, juices and hot drinks

Decide early whether soft drinks and hot drinks belong in your beverage cost percentage at all. Many venues include them, because they are drinks and they appear on the same part of the bill. Others keep the figure for alcohol and put coffee and soft drinks on a line of their own.

Either choice works, but each has a consequence. Soft drinks and coffee usually run at a much lower cost than alcohol, so including them pulls the total down and makes the bar look better. A venue that sells a lot of coffee in the morning can have a fine total and a poor bar. Whichever you choose, write it down and keep it. A figure whose definition changes from month to month cannot be compared with itself.

Low and no alcohol drinks

Alcohol-free beers, spirits and wines now sit on most drinks lists, and they deserve a moment's thought. Their costs often look more like premium soft drinks than like the alcoholic versions they replace, and they are usually priced closer to the alcoholic drink than to a cola.

If they are a small part of sales, keep them with the category they resemble on the menu: an alcohol-free beer with beer, a zero-alcohol spirit with spirits. If they become a real share of what you sell, give them their own line so you can see whether they earn their place.

Getting cost into each category: coding the invoices

The sales half of the split usually comes from the till. The cost half comes from invoices, and it is where most category figures go wrong. Every line on every drinks invoice has to land in one category.

  • Code each line, not each invoice. A wine merchant who also sells spirits and soft drinks sends one invoice with three categories on it.
  • Spread delivery charges and deposits across the lines they belong to, or leave them out of the drinks figure altogether, and do the same every time.
  • Take credit notes off the category of the product they refer to, in the period they arrive.
  • Record free stock at its cost, not at zero. A free case from a supplier promotion still leaves the shelf when it is sold, and costing it at nothing flatters that category for as long as it lasts.

Code invoices from the invoice itself, not from the supplier's price list, because the two drift apart. Our guide to purchase price variance explains how to catch the drift when it happens.

Counting by category

The count gives the opening and closing stock for each category, so it has to be organised the same way. Group the count sheet by category, in the order the shelves actually run, and count every category at the same point in time, after the last sale of the period and before the first delivery of the next.

Value each line at its cost, from the latest invoice or your costing method, and add up each category separately. Partial bottles matter in a category view, because a wine shelf with twenty open bottles holds real money. Our guide to liquor inventory covers counting open bottles to a tenth, and the bar stock checklist covers the end of night routine that keeps the count honest.

Transfers between categories and out of the bar

Stock that leaves a category without being sold as one of its drinks has to be recorded, or the category carries a cost it did not cause. The most common transfers are these:

  • Wine to the kitchen for sauces, risottos and braises.
  • Spirits to the kitchen or pastry section for flambés and desserts.
  • Juice, fruit and herbs from the kitchen to the bar, which is the same problem the other way round.
  • Spirits from the spirits shelf into house syrups, infusions or batched cocktails, if cocktails are a separate category.

The sums are rarely small. Say the kitchen takes six bottles of house white a week at 40 each, and wine sells 11,250 a week before tax. Those 240 are just over two points of the wine category's figure. Without a transfer record, the wine list looks two points worse than it is, and the kitchen's food cost looks better than it is.

Comps, staff drinks and spoilage

Drinks given away and drinks thrown away belong in the category's cost, because the stock was used. What matters is that they are recorded as what they are. A comp written down is a cost you chose. A comp nobody wrote down is part of the unexplained gap between what the drinks should have cost and what the count says they did.

Record each one against its category: a bottle of wine sent to a table after a complaint, a round for a regular, a staff drink at the end of a shift, a bottle that was corked. Over a month the records turn a vague worry into a figure per category, and a figure can be managed as a policy.

Sales by category, before tax

The sales side has its own traps. The till's categories have to match the stock categories exactly, or the two halves of the sum describe different things. A spirit served as a shot, with a mixer and in a cocktail must each land in the category you decided for it, and so must modifiers such as a double measure or an upgrade to a premium brand.

Take tax and service charge out before dividing. The price a guest pays usually includes VAT or a local sales tax, which is not yours to keep. In the UK, for example, drinks served in a restaurant or bar are standard rated, as HMRC's guidance on catering and VAT explains. Divide by sales before tax in every category, the same way every period.

Packages need a rule of their own. A bottomless brunch or a drinks package sold at one price has to be split between food and drink, and the drink part between categories, before any figure means anything. Pick a split, such as the share each part would have earned at menu prices, write it down and use it every time. Our guide to brunch pricing works through the sums for unlimited drinks.

A worked example: the healthy average

Here is the bar from the opening, with a month of illustrative figures. All sales are before tax.

  • Spirits and cocktails: sales of 60,000 and drinks used costing 9,600, which is 16 per cent.
  • Beer: sales of 30,000 and a cost of 6,300, which is 21 per cent.
  • Soft drinks: sales of 15,000 and a cost of 1,800, which is 12 per cent.
  • Wine: sales of 45,000 and a cost of 17,100, which is 38 per cent.

Together, the bar sold 150,000 and used drinks costing 34,800. Its beverage cost percentage for the month is 23.2 per cent, comfortably under the 24 per cent the owner aims for.

Now read the wine line on its own. If the owner's own target for wine is 30 per cent, the category should have used drinks costing 13,500. It used 17,100. That is 3,600 a month over target, or 43,200 a year, and it never showed in the total because spirits, beer and soft drinks were all running a little better than their targets and covered it.

Mix and rate: why the total moves

When the total moves, two different things can have moved it. One is the rate: a category's own figure went up or down. The other is the mix: guests bought more of one category and less of another. The category view lets you separate the two.

Take the same bar a month later. Spirits and cocktails are still at 16 per cent, beer at 21 and soft drinks at 12, but wine has slipped further, to 44 per cent. A cocktail promotion has also moved the mix. Spirits and cocktails rise from 40 to 46 per cent of sales, beer from 20 to 22, soft drinks stay at 10, and wine falls from 30 to 22 per cent.

The total for the new month is 22.9 per cent. It has gone down, by about a third of a point, in the month the wine list got six points worse. A manager reading only the total would congratulate the team.

The split shows what happened. At last month's rates, the new mix alone would have taken the total from 23.2 to 21.5 per cent, a fall of 1.7 points, because the bar sold less of its most expensive category. The wine rate rising by 6 points, on 22 per cent of sales, added back 1.3 points. The two together give the small fall in the total, and only one of them was good news.

Setting a target for each category

A single target for the bar has the same weakness as a single figure: it only makes sense for one particular mix. Targets work far better category by category, each one set from your own history, your own prices and the kind of drinks you sell.

From the category targets, the bar's overall target follows. Suppose the targets are 18 per cent for spirits and cocktails, 24 for beer, 15 for soft drinks and 30 for wine. At the first month's mix, 40, 20, 10 and 30 per cent of sales, the bar's own target works out at 22.5 per cent.

That changes the reading of the example. The bar's 23.2 per cent looked fine against a round 24 borrowed from somewhere else. Against the 22.5 its own mix implies, it is 0.7 points over, with three categories under target and one well over. Work the overall target out from the mix each period, and the total becomes a fair check on the categories rather than a cover for them.

What a category figure can and cannot tell you

A category figure is a ratio, and ratios favour cheap products. A category can run at a low percentage and still leave little cash, and a premium category can run high and earn the most. A bottle of wine that costs 120 and sells for 360 before tax runs at 33 per cent and leaves 240. A soft drink that costs 1.50 and sells for 15 runs at 10 per cent and leaves 13.50.

So use the category figure for what it is good at: catching drift, separating mix from rate and pointing at the shelf where cost has gone wrong. To decide what to sell, look at the cash each drink leaves. Our explainer on gross profit per dish makes the case for food, and it applies to a glass exactly as it does to a plate.

When one category is off: where to look

A category that runs above its target usually has a short list of causes. Start with the ones that fit the category.

  • Wine: glass sizes against the menu, bottles opened for tastings, open bottles poured away, a glass price that has not kept up with the bottle price, and wine taken by the kitchen without a record.
  • Spirits and cocktails: over pour on the house spirits, premium upgrades priced as a flat surcharge, house syrups costed once and never again, and cocktail specs the team has drifted from.
  • Draught beer: line cleaning and keg changes that are not recorded, pints poured away, and a keg yield that assumes every drop is sold.
  • Bottled beer and soft drinks: breakage, drinks given to staff, out of date stock, and for post-mix soft drinks, a ratio set too strong.

Then check the paperwork before the bar. A category that jumps by several points in one period is as often an invoice coded to the wrong line, a missing credit note or a count done on the wrong day as it is a real loss.

Pour cost and the category figure together

Pour cost is the building block, and the category figure is the check on it. If every drink in a category has a costed recipe, you can multiply each one's cost by the number sold, add them up and divide by the category's sales. That gives the theoretical figure: what the category should have cost if every drink had been made exactly to its spec.

The actual figure, from the count, says what it really cost. Put the two side by side for each category and the gap between them tells you how much went missing, and where. Our guide to actual vs theoretical food cost explains the kitchen version of the same comparison.

Reading the gap category by category

A gap spread thinly across every category is a different problem from one concentrated in a single category. A thin, even gap often means a general habit, such as free pouring, generous measures or loose comps. A gap in one category usually has one cause you can find.

Keep the gap for each category, period by period, and read it as a line rather than a number. A wine gap of three points every month is a known cost of selling wine by the glass, and you can decide whether to accept it. A wine gap that grows from one point to five over a quarter is something changing, and it is worth finding out what.

How often to work it out

The category figure is only as good as the count behind it, so it runs on the count's rhythm. A bar that counts weekly can work out its figures weekly, and should, because a problem found in a week costs a quarter of one found in a month. Counting monthly is the minimum for any bar that takes drinks seriously.

Whatever the rhythm, keep it fixed. Count on the same day, at the same point in trading, and close the purchases and sales for exactly the same period. A count done on a Monday morning one week and a Sunday night the next will show movements that are only the calendar.

A one-page category report

The weekly or monthly report needs one line per category and a handful of columns. Keep it on one page, in the same order every time:

  • The category.
  • Sales before tax.
  • Opening stock, purchases, transfers in and out, and closing stock, all at cost.
  • The cost of drinks used, and the category's beverage cost percentage.
  • The category's target, and the gap in points and in money.
  • The same figure for the last period and for the same period last year, where you have it.

Under the lines, add the bar's total and the overall target worked out from that period's mix. Then add a short note for anything that explains a movement: a price rise from a supplier, a new wine list, a promotion or an event. The note matters more than it looks, because in three months nobody will remember why wine jumped in one week.

Common mistakes

  • Reading only the total, and taking a stable total as proof that nothing changed.
  • Comparing the total with a target borrowed from a different kind of venue.
  • Letting soft drinks and coffee drift in and out of the definition.
  • Coding invoices by supplier instead of by line.
  • Leaving wine used in the kitchen, and spirits used in the pastry section, in the bar's categories.
  • Costing free stock at zero.
  • Dividing by sales that include tax or service charge.
  • Calling a category healthy because its percentage is low, without looking at the cash it leaves.

Each of these makes the figures friendlier and less useful. The aim is not low numbers. It is true ones, in the right places.

Where ServeAround fits

The category split needs three things: sales by category, a cost behind each drink, and a count. ServeAround covers the first two in full and the third in part.

Every drink rung through the point of sale lands in the menu report in Analytics, whose Sales by category panel shows each menu category's revenue, units, share of revenue and margin over any range of dates. Its table also says how many drinks in each category have a cost behind them and how many do not. Set up your menu categories the way you want to read the bar, such as Spirits, Cocktails, Wine by the glass, Beer and Soft drinks, and those become the report's categories.

With inventory, part of Order Fulfillment, each drink gets a recipe. A recipe can take millilitres from a bottle counted in litres, and it gives the drink's cost, its menu price, its margin and its cost as a percentage of the price, at today's stock costs.

The menu report's category margin is worked out over the part of each category's revenue that has a cost behind it, so 100 minus that margin is the theoretical beverage cost percentage for the category's costed drinks. Costs have no history, so last month's margin uses this month's costs. If your menu prices include tax, these percentages are over prices with tax in them, and read a little lower than the sum in this guide.

Inventory items carry a category, Drinks among them, and a storage area such as Bar or Cellar, and a count can cover one storage area at a time, set against the expected stock with the variance item by item and at cost. Waste can be recorded with a reason, such as complimentary, staff meal or dropped or broken, at what the stock cost that day.

Recipes can be filtered to those over the venue's food cost target, which is one target for every dish and drink, so read drinks against your own category targets rather than that filter. The inventory report gives a theoretical cost for all costed dishes and drinks together, not by drinks category, and the actual figure for each category, from opening stock, purchases, transfers and closing stock, is still your own sheet. If you would like to see it on your own menu, get in touch.

Questions operators ask

What is a good beverage cost percentage?

There is no single good figure, for the whole bar or for any category. A cocktail bar, a pub and a restaurant with a serious wine list run different costs for sound reasons. Measure your own figures by category for several weeks, set a target for each from what you find and what your prices allow, and work the overall target out from the mix.

Is beverage cost percentage the same as pour cost?

They divide the same things, the cost of drinks by drinks sales before tax, so the sums are alike. Pour cost is usually used for a single drink or for the bar's alcohol, and beverage cost percentage for a whole category or the drinks line of the accounts. Choose a definition for each and keep it.

Should soft drinks and coffee be included?

That is your choice, but make it once. Including them lowers the total, because they usually cost less than alcohol. If you include them, give them their own category so their low cost cannot hide a problem elsewhere.

How many categories should a bar use?

Four or five to start: spirits and cocktails, wine, beer, and soft and hot drinks, with low and no alcohol drinks wherever they sit on the menu. Split one further when you have a reason to watch it alone, because each category adds work to the count and the invoices.

Why did our total fall when one category got worse?

Because the mix moved. If guests bought less of your most expensive category, the total falls even if that category's own figure rose. Separate the two effects with the method in the mix and rate section, and read the categories before the total.

How do we handle a drinks package or a bottomless brunch?

Split the package price between food and drink, and the drink part between categories, using a rule you write down and keep, such as the share each part would earn at menu prices. Without a rule the package lands wherever the till puts it, and the categories stop meaning anything.

Do comps and staff drinks belong in the category cost?

Yes, because the stock was used. Record each one against its category as it happens. Recorded, they become a known line you can manage. Unrecorded, they sit in the unexplained gap between theoretical and actual.

How do we stop the kitchen's wine landing on the bar?

Record every bottle the kitchen takes as a transfer out of the wine category, at cost, and into the kitchen's food cost. A simple sheet behind the bar, initialled by whoever takes the bottle, is enough. Add the transfers up when you close the period.

The short version

A single beverage cost percentage is a weighted average, and it can sit comfortably while one category loses money. Split it into four or five categories, code every invoice line to one of them, count by category and record transfers, comps and waste. Divide each category's cost by its sales before tax.

Set a target for each category, work the overall target out from the mix, and when the total moves, separate the mix from the rate before you react. Then look at the category that is off, the shelf it sits on and the paperwork behind it, in that order.

Written byThe ServeAround team

Keep reading